Sierra Club Canada: Great Lakes organizations alarmed with IJC’s ‘advice’

Great Lakes organizations alarmed with the International Joint Commission’s “Adaptive Management” advice instead of dealing with a significant cause of the record-setting low water levels on Lakes Michigan/Huron/Georgian Bay

By:  Sierra Club Canada:

Sierra Club CanadaTORONTO – As water levels in Lakes Michigan, Huron and Georgian Bay set new monthly record lows, the International Joint Commission (IJC) has recently sent signals that it will ignore the public’s concern and request for a viable solution, announcing instead a ‘Great Lakes Regional Adaptive Management Plan’.

In January of 2013, American IJC Commissioner Dareth Glance acknowledged that water levels were getting lower but still “within historical ranges”. Ms. Glance said that because there is “so much uncertainty”, both the Canadian and American governments should simply ‘adapt’ to the reality of lower water levels.

Sierra Club Canada IJC article image 1

However water levels in Michigan/Huron/Georgian Bay have declined far more than those of the other Great Lakes and show no signs of either leveling off or rising after 13 years of low levels. Ongoing erosion from earlier dredging of the St. Clair River and removal of the sand content of the water is causing excess outflow from Michigan/Huron/Georgian Bay through the lower lakes and out into the Atlantic Ocean. This in turn results in local wetlands being drained and shorelines exposed to new invasive species, causing the ecosystem to deteriorate rapidly.

The Commissioners did hear a loud and clear message at their summer 2012 public hearings around the Great Lakes – “Restore Our Water Levels.” At the conclusion of the IJC hearings Canadian Commissioner Lyall Knott said “we hear you loud and clear – restore our water levels.” The over 1,200 public attendees at the Georgian Bay hearings alone will not be happy to learn the IJC is now telling them to get used to lower water levels. The one thing that is not needed now is more “study”. “We need solutions now,” says Mary Muter, the Chair of the Sierra Club Ontario’s Great Lakes Section.

“We expect the recent numbers to get worse, compounding the effects,” says Dr. Pat Chow-Fraser, Director of Life Sciences at McMaster University, who monitors the damage to the ecosystem. “Lack of snow and ice means more evaporation in winter, and even lower water levels next spring. The Michigan/Huron/Georgian Bay ecosystem is being affected most profoundly.”

SONY DSCA viable solution to the water loss was submitted to the IJC by the Sierra Club, a national environmental organization, in the summer of 2012. It proposed submerged sills, or water ‘speed bumps’, in the St. Clair River, which would slow down the water flow and allow the Michigan/Huron/Georgian Bay levels to rise gradually over time – and allow wetlands to flood again, fish to be able to get into rivers to spawn again. These sills are based on a design agreed upon by both Canada and the US in 1962, and their shared cost over several years would be an estimated $200-million (CDN) to install. This price tag is a bargain compared to the cost of doing nothing except to keep dredging and blasting to maintain access. Local stakeholders are watching the frightful scene of billions of dollars being lost due to lightly loaded cargo ships, dried up harbours, marinas and wetlands, a steady decline in recreational fishing, and continued algal blooms.

“At these numbers, it would take years of consistent rain to naturally improve the situation.” says Roger Gauthier, a retired hydrologist of the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) “Continued dredging and blasting on Michigan/Huron/Georgian Bay can only do so much. We cannot continue to spend billions of dollars when there is a viable economically and environmentally responsible solution. Both our countries agreed to compensation and it is high time the terms of that agreement were now met.”

“The cost of doing nothing now is in the billions – and increased ecosystem damage” says Mary Muter. “Water levels can be restored responsibly by gradually installing sills at the head of the St. Clair River to meet the terms of the 1956 bi-national agreement as a condition of dredging the St. Clair River for the St. Lawrence Seaway Project. It’s time for governments to work together to finish the job, before we have further disasters.”

For more information, please visit where there is background information on this crisis.

Images: Sierra Club Canada

The Canadian Progressive recommends:



The following two tabs change content below.

Guest Blog

Blog posts by guest bloggers, including press releases and content from other publications.