The Canadian Progressive

Hard-hitting, provocative, unapologetic, activism-oriented political news and analysis

Immigration and Refugee Board Adjucator David McBean Must Go


by Obert Madondo | The Canadian Progressive, March 11, 2011:

UNHCRflag.svg  150x150 Immigration and Refugee Board Adjucator David McBean Must Go

How disappointing that Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s Conservative government reappointed Immigration and Refugee Board adjudicator, David McBean, to another five-year term after he rejected all 169 cases he adjudicated since 2007. McBean’s record automatically strikes terror in the heart of any would-be refugee. I’m speaking from personal experience.

I arrived in Canada as a political refugee from Zimbabwe in August, 2003. Although the IRB expedited my case, the weeks leading to my hearing were tortuous. I dreaded the possibility losing my meritorious case and returning to the waiting jaws of Robert Mugabe, the genocidal dictator of Zimbabwe. Within three months, the IRB had accepted my refugee application. Canada restored my stolen dignity and gave me a fresh start in life.

Read more about my life on these memoir writings on The Canadian Progressive blog.

McBean’s motives in rejecting 169 different personal stories of potential persecution and even death should even be subject of speculation. Surely, it’s a remarkable coincidence that all lacked credibility.

McBean is anti-immigrant. He is the very antithesis of Canada’s compassion-based refugee determinant system.Most importantly, his record shamed the principles of the 1951 Refugee Convention of the United Nations Commission for Refugees (UNHCR). The convention legally defines “who is a refugee, their rights and the legal obligations of states.”

McBean is the quintessential “ugly Canadian“.

The government should preserve the integrity of our incomparable refugee determinant system and revoke McBean’s reappointment.

The Canadian Progressive recommends:



Obert Madondo is an Ottawa-based activist and progressive political blogger. He's the founder and publisher of The Canadian Progressive blog and numerous other online publications.

View all posts by
Stu Craine
Stu Craine

my personal belief: what else would you really expect from a Harper lackey...